The Fighting 69th

This is a remarkable movie, though you might not guess it from the credits. I don't know what George Brent was doing in movies; he certainly couldn't act, and that is painfully obvious here. But Cagney gives a superlative performance, once again going out on a limb, this time by playing a coward. And while he does finally find some courage, he is not rewarded with love and kisses; he dies. In short, it would be hard to imagine Hollywood making a movie like this today, but it is most definitely worth seeing. Sometimes the speeches get a little preachy, but all the sentiments are good ones, and as a realistic study of the difficulties of dealing with the horrors of war, this is one remarkable movie, for any time. A great script and and some first-rate acting.

source: The Fighting 69th

Trailer—The Fighting 69th

The Fighting 69th

This movie is a rehash of Angels With Dirty Faces but with grenades instead of electric chairs. Father Nice Guy (Pat O Brien) offers Jerry Plunkett a solution to all of his cowardice. He should either be thrown onto a grenade or go to the electric chair. Plunkett is not too keen on the electric chair ( His cousin, Rocky Sullivan died screaming and begging on the way to one) so he figures if he's gonna die he'd better be dragged toward a live grenade. Predictably, the moment comes and Plunkett's comrades drag him toward a live grenade and throw him onto it. This has been done before and much better.

It's 1917. Brash troublemaking misfit New Yorker Jerry Plunkett (James Cagney) is training to be sent off to war. He's part of the 69th New York Irishmen. His bravado is first revealed to be false when he faints after getting a shot. It continues onto the battlefield. As he faces court-martialed, he is given a second chance. This is a pro-military, pro-unity film as war looms for America. Cagney is a his tough guy persona but in this, he is shown to be a coward when real heat is applied. That's an interesting twist and that makes this interesting. He still gets his heroic redemption. In the meanwhile, it is a lot of sermons and good intention from Father Duffy. Overall, this does what it intents to do and it does it well.

This isn't exactly the most realistic or subtle film Cagney or Warner Brothers ever made. However, despite being a piece of unbelievable fluff, it still is very entertaining--with lots of action and histrionic performances--particularly from Cagney. He plays a blow-hard who acts tough but knuckles under in action during WWI. In fact, for cowardice in action he is sentenced to death and must choose whether to go out like a man or die as a lily-livered coward. Considering it's pure Hollywood hokum, it's not hard to figure out how he'll make his final exit. So, in summary it's VERY formulaic and silly but still worth a watch just because it's so entertaining.