Narrator

Heather Donahue

Michael DeCoto, Montgomery College Film professor

Rachel Meyer, Heather Donahue's best friend

Randy Donahue, Heather Donahue's grandfather

Burkittsville resident Interviewee

Joshua 'Josh' Leonard

Lisa Toller

Michael 'Mike' Williams

Tom Williams

News presenter Joseph Nagy

News presenter Minette Marcial

Burkittsville sheriff Ronald Cravens

Dottie Fulcher

Lucan Johnson

Charles Moorehouse, professor of folklore at Hampshire College

Burkittsville historian Bill Barnes

Rustin Parr